[independent media
centre]
הפש
English
Hebrew
Arabic

שופיח

םדקתמ שופיח


תא יפיסוה
תמישרל ךלש לאודה
ונלש הצופתה
ךל חלשנ ונאו
.םינוכדע

רמאמ םסרפ
,טסקט חלש
וא לוק ,תונומת
תורישי ואדיו
.השילגה תנכותמ
תושדח
ינכדע רוקיס
.םיעורא לש
קזבמ
יאנותיעה התא
!ךמצע לש
םיעורא ןמוי
האחמ ,םיעורא
תויוליעפו
סקדניא
םירתאל םירושיק
ןאכ
ןאכ תעה בתכ
וידר
טנרטניא וידר
ואדיו
יחרזא ןמוי
םילבכב קבאמ



www.indymedia.org

Projects
climate
print
radio
satellite tv
video

Africa
ambazonia
nigeria
south africa

Canada
alberta
hamilton
maritimes
montreal
ontario
ottawa
quebec
thunder bay
vancouver
victoria
windsor

East Asia
japan

Europe
athens
austria
barcelona
belgium
bristol
cyprus
euskal herria
finland
galiza
germany
hungary
ireland
istanbul
italy
lille
madrid
nantes
netherlands
nice
norway
paris
poland
portugal
prague
russia
sweden
switzerland
thessaloniki
united kingdom
west vlaanderen

Latin America
argentina
bolivia
brasil
chiapas
chile
colombia
ecuador
mexico
peru
qollasuyu
rosario
sonora
tijuana
uruguay

Pacific
adelaide
aotearoa
brisbane
jakarta
melbourne
perth
sydney

South Asia
india
mumbai

United States
arizona
arkansas
atlanta
austin
baltimore
boston
buffalo
chicago
cleveland
danbury, ct
dc
hawaii
houston
idaho
ithaca
la
madison
maine
michigan
milwaukee
minneapolis/st. paul
new jersey
new mexico
north carolina
north texas
ny capital
nyc
oklahoma
philadelphia
pittsburgh
portland
richmond
rochester
rocky mountain
rogue valley
san diego
san francisco bay area
santa cruz, ca
seattle
st louis
tallahassee-red hills
urbana-champaign
utah
vermont
western mass

West Asia
beirut
israel
palestine

Process
discussion
fbi/legal updates
indymedia faq
mailing lists
process & imc docs
tech
volunteer

 

 


technlogy by cat@lyst and IMC Geeks

Hosting sponsored by:
sweethome

indymedia news about us

Israel's settlement quandary
by Raffi Berg 2:39pm Wed Aug 20 '03

In the end, demographics may be the deciding factor in the debate over the future of the settlements. "If you add to the number of settlers about 250,000 Jews living in neighbourhoods beyond the old demarcation line in Jerusalem, whom the Palestinians view as settlers as much as anywhere else, you're talking about half a million people - about 8% of the Israeli population," said Shlomo Avineri, a professor of political science at Jerusalem's Hebrew University
print article

Raffi Berg explores public opinion in Israel:

At his food stand in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem, Buddy Frankel, an Orthodox Jew from New York, serves up a hotdog as he gathers his thoughts.

"I don't think there is any such thing as land for peace," he says in a broad Bronx accent.

"As far as I feel, we've got a God-given right to settle any part of the land. The settlements should be left there and more people brought in to settle the land."
His customer, Athina Derasmo, a fellow immigrant from the United States, sharply disagrees.

"Giving up settlements will show good faith," she says. "Palestinians are attached to this land just as much as Jews."

Of all the issues which divide Israelis over the peace process, there is perhaps the least consensus over what to do about the Jewish settlements in the West Bank and Gaza.

While the vast majority of Israelis agree that Jews have a historical claim to the land, whether settlements should be removed and land surrendered to the Palestinians in return for peace is the subject of much debate.

The US-backed roadmap to peace calls on Israel to take "action on settlements in conjunction with the establishment of a Palestinian state", based on the principle of land for peace, and for the Palestinians to end violence against Israel for good.

"In the long-run, most of the settlements should be removed, but terrorism is also a problem and it's naive to say once we start removing settlements terrorism will go," said 26-year-old Clara Unger, a civil servant in Jerusalem.

*******************
JEWISH SETTLEMENTS
Widely regarded by international community as illegal under international law according to Fourth Geneva Convention (article 49), which prohibits an occupying power transferring citizens from its own territory to occupied territory
Israel argues international conventions relating to occupied land do not apply to West Bank and Gaza, because they were not under the legitimate sovereignty of any state in the first place
*******************

Seventeen-year-old student Jonny Greenwald shook his head in disapproval.
"Removing settlements is not the right thing to do," he said. "The Palestinians aren't keeping to their side of the deal and they are just using what they call occupation to keep attacking Israel."

Another student, 18-year-old David Shukrun, said the settlements should stay because "the West Bank has become part of this land and we can't separate it."

Three years ago, when the peace camp was in the ascendant, former Prime Minister Ehud Barak reportedly offered to dismantle 63 settlements and withdraw from 97% of the West Bank.

But since the outbreak of the Palestinian uprising months later, there has been a complete breakdown in trust, and opinions as to the merits of ceding land have hardened.

"Far fewer Israelis believe the Palestinians after three years of terror," said Nadav Shragai, a commentator for the centre-left Israeli newspaper Haaretz.


"More Israelis now support the settlements, because they saw in the last few years that Palestinians attacked towns in Israel as well as settlements in the West Bank. So Israelis sympathise with the settlers more, because they have suffered from the same terror."
It is an observation supported by a recent opinion poll which suggested that Israelis were growing averse to the prospect of evacuating settlements.

According to a recent survey by the Jerusalem-based Harry S Truman Institute for the Advancement of Peace, 43% of Israelis believe settlers should resist a government order to evacuate settlements, compared to just 12% last year.

Today, about 220,000 Jews live in the West Bank and observers note it would be impossible to uproot and relocate so many settlers.

Even Ehud Barak spoke of leaving 80% of settlers - those who live close to Israel's pre-1967 border - in their homes in a final status deal.
In the end, demographics may be the deciding factor in the debate over the future of the settlements.

"If you add to the number of settlers about 250,000 Jews living in neighbourhoods beyond the old demarcation line in Jerusalem, whom the Palestinians view as settlers as much as anywhere else, you're talking about half a million people - about 8% of the Israeli population," said Shlomo Avineri, a professor of political science at Jerusalem's Hebrew University.

"There are very few precedents in history where 8% of a population has been moved, which makes the reality of this happening - regardless of the legal arguments - highly problematic. But it's being lost in the noise of claims and counter-claims of both sides.

"So even if you think this is what should be done, it's not going to be done overnight. You need a lot of money to do it, it will take three to five years to build houses and infrastructure.

"In the meantime, a lot of things are happening on the ground and they will prove hard to undo."

news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3145365....

add your comments

Source file


 

(C) Indymedia Israel. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Indymedia Israel.